|
Noisy voices on the right and on the left are busy trying to kill the most practical immigration compromise this country has seen in years. If we let them. But I’m hopeful that there are enough of us who see sufficient good in the comprehensive proposal agreed to by the President and a bipartisan group of Senators enough of us who deal more with the reality of immigration than with the rhetoric who will stand up to all the noise and provide the reasoned voices that can spur Congress to pass the immigration bill.
The recent release of a poll showing that a strong majority of Americans, including nearly two-thirds of Republicans, support legalization for immigrants should come as no surprise in California, where we experience daily the positive impact immigrants have on our economy and our community. But those numbers are news in that they demonstrate the existence of a broad based, broadminded “society of the center” that has the potential to frame the discussion on immigration and generate congressional support for the current bill.
Clearly, the complexities of the nation’s immigration policy cannot be fixed in any one particular piece of legislation. Neither can tax policy, energy policy or environmental policy. All are issues that take time and a series of layered steps to fully address. The immigration bill, which President Bush and Senate Majority Leader Reid are working to bring back to life on the Senate Floor, fits that process.
Three of its key elements are items that reasonable people agree we need. Few Americans disagree with the concept of thoughtfully tightening and securing US borders, efforts which can include
|
added border personnel, electronic surveillance systems, and effective diplomacy with Mexico and other nations. Many Americans, especially those in agriculture, also agree that the US economy is dependent on some sort of system for providing seasonal workers. And, as that latest poll shows, a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants who pay their taxes and learn English is a path thoughtful Americans are comfortable with.
Reasonable people also agree that though the current bill is nearly 1,000 pages in length, it does not and can not resolve all the conceivable issues attached to immigration. There are remaining questions about family unification, taxation and benefits, employer responsibility in hiring, language, and stopping human traffickers. These issues are real and important and definitely need to be addressed in further legislation.
On the left, distrust of President Bush over the war and other issues makes it difficult to proffer support to him even when, as in this case, it may be deserved. On the right, talk radio is a powerful megaphone that can distort the message received by many politicians on that side of the aisle. The rest of us in the society of the center have to rise above all that and make our voices heard if we want to see any real change in the current immigration situation.
It is our responsibility, in the society of the center, to stand up, speak out, and support these vital and workable first steps. If we do, we have the potential to not only save the current immigration bill, but to reframe the entire immigration discussion away from the existing and exhausting partisan polarization we see now. Silence may be golden, but here it only costs us a golden opportunity.
|